1684 Words7 Pages

The Effect of Think Alouds on Mathematical Reasoning

Chrystal Paddock

Concordia University

The Effects of Think Alouds on Mathematical Reasoning

This literature review endeavors to draw connections between several studies regarding thinking aloud and mathematical reasoning in mathematics classrooms. This review investigates the question: do think alouds in middle school improve mathematical reasoning? Mathematical reasoning involves formulating conjectures, sense-making with mathematical concepts and making reasonable judgements, which may serve to support inquiry and exploration. From group collaboration to individual work, students were prompted to vocalize their thinking and understanding in various settings in an attempt to*…show more content…*

Self-explanation

Self-explanation is the process of describing understanding as expressed in one’s own words. Think alouds engage students in self-explanation, describing their mathematical process and reasoning. Monaghan (2005) found that students benefit from externalizing their own thinking. Reviewing transcribed group conversations uncovers students sharing mathematical processes and thinking and leveraging their understanding to present and support a convincing argument for the mathematical processes chosen (Monaghan, 2005). This not only accomplishes effective group collaboration resulting in more accurate and complete work, but under the ground rules, provided each member an opportunity to vocally contribute. Chi, et al. (1994) discuss the implications of self-explanation comparing a control group of students who recites and excerpt from a text twice to the test group who recites the same text, but after each passage is prompted to self-explain. Overwhelmingly the test group outperformed the control group, more accurately and more completely recalling circulatory system knowledge. These findings have a potentially profound impact on math students engaging in think alouds. Montague et al. (1993) and Rosenzweig et al. (2011) also made extensive use of think alouds, but the purpose was to vocalize thought to evaluate for cognitive and

Chrystal Paddock

Concordia University

The Effects of Think Alouds on Mathematical Reasoning

This literature review endeavors to draw connections between several studies regarding thinking aloud and mathematical reasoning in mathematics classrooms. This review investigates the question: do think alouds in middle school improve mathematical reasoning? Mathematical reasoning involves formulating conjectures, sense-making with mathematical concepts and making reasonable judgements, which may serve to support inquiry and exploration. From group collaboration to individual work, students were prompted to vocalize their thinking and understanding in various settings in an attempt to

Self-explanation

Self-explanation is the process of describing understanding as expressed in one’s own words. Think alouds engage students in self-explanation, describing their mathematical process and reasoning. Monaghan (2005) found that students benefit from externalizing their own thinking. Reviewing transcribed group conversations uncovers students sharing mathematical processes and thinking and leveraging their understanding to present and support a convincing argument for the mathematical processes chosen (Monaghan, 2005). This not only accomplishes effective group collaboration resulting in more accurate and complete work, but under the ground rules, provided each member an opportunity to vocally contribute. Chi, et al. (1994) discuss the implications of self-explanation comparing a control group of students who recites and excerpt from a text twice to the test group who recites the same text, but after each passage is prompted to self-explain. Overwhelmingly the test group outperformed the control group, more accurately and more completely recalling circulatory system knowledge. These findings have a potentially profound impact on math students engaging in think alouds. Montague et al. (1993) and Rosenzweig et al. (2011) also made extensive use of think alouds, but the purpose was to vocalize thought to evaluate for cognitive and

Related

## Procedural Difficiency Paper

1164 Words | 5 PagesCurrent mathematics researchers emphasize three areas of mathematical abilities. They are procedural knowledge, procedural flexibility, and conceptual knowledge (Kilpatrick, Swafford, & Findell, 2001; Rittle-Johnson & Star, 2007; Bottge, Rueda, LaRoque, Serlin, & Kwon, 2007). Procedural knowledge is the understanding basic skills or the sequence of steps needed to solve math problems. Procedural flexibility is knowing the many different ways in which a particular problem can be solved. Since I teach

## The Theories Of Cognitive Development On The Curriculum And Instructional Strategies Used Within The Targeted Instructional Setting

2170 Words | 9 PagesThis paper will briefly describe the targeted instructional setting that is the foundation for the discussion that follows. Then this paper will present the implications of several theories of cognitive development on the curriculum and instructional strategies used within the targeted instructional setting. These include the cognitive development theories of Jean Piaget and Lev Vygotsky, among others. Based on these theories, two recommended adjustments to the curriculum content for the targeted

## Why Math Is Important For Teaching Mathematics And How Students Learn Mathematics

870 Words | 4 Pagesmathematics will have significant opportunities and options for shaping their future. (NCTM 2000, p.50). The two important tools to be an effective teacher is knowledge of mathematics and how students learn mathematics. The purposes of math education effect our life since the time we were able to walk. We were taught how to count on our fingers to being able to write our numbers to ten. Then as we got older, concepts were more challenging and involved critical thinking to solve the problems. In society

## A Learner's Social Factors Affecting Mathematics Numeracy Learning

5536 Words | 22 PagesPersonal interview a learner social factors affecting mathematics numeracy learning Introduction Mathematics is a type of reasoning. Thinking mathematically includes thinking in a rational way, developing and checking conjectures, understanding things, and forming and validating judgments, reasoning, and conclusions. We show mathematical habits when we acknowledge and explain patterns, build physical and theoretical models of sensations, develop sign systems to assist us stand for, control, and

## Teaching Methods For Students With Learning Difficulties

1802 Words | 8 PagesEducators continue to debate which instructional method is the most effective for students with learning difficulties in regular classrooms. Despite the continued deliberation over which teaching method is best suited to the teaching of mathematics to students with learning difficulties, explicit teaching has overwhelming come out on top. According to mathematic intervention research explicit instruction is one of the most effective instructional approaches. This paper will put forward the arguments

## Methods of Instruction for Teaching Mathematics Essay

1879 Words | 8 PagesMention the word math and a considerable number of people are sure to express their aversion to the subject. To illustrate: Raytheon Corporation surveyed approximately 1,000 adulterants whether they would prefer to eat broccoli or to work on a problem in mathematics. The preponderance of the students picked broccoli. The terror of math encompasses into later life. According to research by the non-profit institute Change the Equation in 2010, nearly one-third of Americans would rather clean an

## Role of Music

2461 Words | 10 Pagesbut learning which harmonies or chords should be sung/played and often correcting each other. In what seems to be no time at all, most students are happy to put their talents “on parade”. I was a very shy student and rarely asked questions aloud in class. Part of that was personality, but part of that was the presence of particular educators in class who made you feel lower than dirt and that you were stupid if you asked questions when you didn’t understand. As a result, I learned to

## The Confessions, Book Xi : Time And Eternity

2932 Words | 12 PagesTHY 600 Research Paper Joe Stocker Augustine 's Confessions, Book XI: Time and Eternity Augustine 's Confessions is a series of complex books that he compiled to elucidate his relationship with an all-powerful, all-knowing and all-loving God who is also the Creator of all things. Confessions recapitulates that those who have commenced their return to God must acknowledge their state before God so that He might set them free. It should be mentioned that Chan and Outler each point out that the word

## A Philosophy of Education: In Experience there is Direction Essay

3696 Words | 15 PagesA Philosophy of Education: In Experience there is Direction Abstract I believe that greatness is within all of us; we just need a little help finding it sometimes. I have come to understand that one caring person can make all the difference in someone else’s life. As I venture further into my teaching career, I hope to help my students to Education is a journey of seeking answers and experiencing. Every human being has the ability to learn and apply meaning to education. Learners should

## Collaboration Can Have Powerful Effects On Student Learning

9230 Words | 37 PagesInteractions producing elaborated explanations are particularly valuable for improving student learning. Nonresponsive feedback, on the other hand, can be detrimental to student learning in collaborative situations. Collaboration can have powerful effects on student learning, particularly for low-achieving students. However, a number of factors may moderate the impact of collaboration on student learning, including student characteristics, group composition, and task characteristics. Although historical

### Procedural Difficiency Paper

1164 Words | 5 Pages### The Theories Of Cognitive Development On The Curriculum And Instructional Strategies Used Within The Targeted Instructional Setting

2170 Words | 9 Pages### Why Math Is Important For Teaching Mathematics And How Students Learn Mathematics

870 Words | 4 Pages### A Learner's Social Factors Affecting Mathematics Numeracy Learning

5536 Words | 22 Pages### Teaching Methods For Students With Learning Difficulties

1802 Words | 8 Pages### Methods of Instruction for Teaching Mathematics Essay

1879 Words | 8 Pages### Role of Music

2461 Words | 10 Pages### The Confessions, Book Xi : Time And Eternity

2932 Words | 12 Pages### A Philosophy of Education: In Experience there is Direction Essay

3696 Words | 15 Pages### Collaboration Can Have Powerful Effects On Student Learning

9230 Words | 37 Pages

- In Exercises 3338 Use A Double Integral In Polar
- Suppose That The Base Of The Square Pyramid In
- What Are The Key Skills That Successful Managers Should
- Minimizing Construction Costs A Man Wishes To Construct A
- Recall List The Components Of Eukaryotic Pol Ii Promoters
- Imagine That You Stand Tall And Turn About A
- What Are The Challenges In Design
- In Exhibit 11 Assume An Equilibrium With An Interest
- Complete The Following Nuclear Reactions An714h11o817bl37ih11h24e
- You Add 0255 G Of An Orange Crystalline Compound
- Evaluating A Logarithm Using Technology In Exercises 5 8
- A Function Is Given By A Table Of Values
- Accounts Receivable Turnover And Days Sales In Receivables Hj
- Using Power Series Let Letfxn1x2n12n1gxn0x2n2n A Find The Intervals
- Prove The Statement Using The Definition Of A Limit
- Label Each Of The Following Statements As Either True
- Tax Rate Of Suppose Taxes Are Related To Income
- How Are Granules And Super Granules Related How Do
- Factor Each Trinomial Completely R212r27
- Discuss Polynomials Of Odd Degree The Conjugate Zeros Theorem
- Assume That It Is True That Polly Sings Well